Podcast: Play in new window
Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | Spotify | RSS
In today’s video, I discuss whether retroactive jealousy is a “real thing,” and address common misconceptions about it.
Read or watch below to hear my response to the question: “Is retroactive jealousy a real thing?”
Zachary Stockill: Whenever you post something online—especially on platforms like YouTube or podcasts—you’re bound to attract trolls and haters.
As the golden rule of the internet goes, “Don’t feed the trolls.” But in today’s video, perhaps against my better judgment, I’m going to break that rule.
I’ll address a criticism that I find not only frustrating but also potentially harmful to anyone dealing with retroactive jealousy.
If you’re struggling with retroactive jealousy, I think today’s video will be worth your time.
My name is Zachary Stockill, and since 2013, I’ve been helping people from around the world overcome retroactive jealousy and rebuild their relationships.
If you’d like to learn more about my work or explore one-on-one coaching, please click here.
If you’re new here, retroactive jealousy refers to intrusive thoughts, obsessive curiosity, or what I call “mental movies” about your partner’s past relationships or sexual history.
In my view, experiencing even one of these symptoms—or all three—makes you a retroactive jealousy sufferer.
And when you write about retroactive jealousy, when you post about retroactive jealousy, one comment you occasionally get is some variation of this: Retroactive jealousy isn’t really a thing.
This is nonsense. This just means you’re in the wrong relationships. Or this just means your girlfriend is an “insert pejorative here.”
It just means that your boyfriend or husband isn’t the right match… Retroactive jealousy isn’t really a thing; it’s all nonsense.
It just means you should break up and move on.
As I often say, sometimes breaking up is the right choice.
Sometimes, if you take the time to reflect, explore your feelings, think deeply, talk with friends and family, and do some soul-searching, you may realize that your partner doesn’t share your values. If that’s the case, it’s probably time to move on.
However, most people who claim that retroactive jealousy isn’t real have likely never experienced it themselves.
They don’t know what it’s like to go to bed with your partner’s past on your mind, wake up thinking about it, and be tormented by those thoughts multiple times a day.
They don’t understand the mental movies, the curiosity, the compulsive need to know, or the endless questioning.
These people haven’t experienced retroactive jealousy themselves, so their opinions on it should be taken with a grain of salt.
Interestingly, over the years, it’s been almost exclusively men who have made these comments on my YouTube channel and elsewhere.
“Retroactive jealousy isn’t really a thing,” or so some people claim.
Often, it seems like these comments come from guys with issues about women or those caught up in extreme red-pill views about men and women.
Many of them argue that retroactive jealousy isn’t real and that you should just break up and find someone new.
They don’t realize that I’ve worked with people—real retroactive jealousy sufferers—who can’t get past the fact that their partner once had a simple crush on someone else.
Nothing sexual happened, but they can’t stand the idea of their partner even glancing at someone else, and they become completely obsessed with that thought.
Retroactive jealousy isn’t always about sex, and that’s one of the strongest counterarguments to those who claim it’s not a real issue.
It can affect men, women, and trans people alike. I’ve worked with many straight clients, gay clients, and even a few bisexual clients.
Young, old, and everything in between—people from every country on the planet have visited my website, RetroactiveJealousy.com.
That’s not an exaggeration; I’ve checked. Visitors from over 190 countries, from every background, race, ethnic group, religion, and spiritual belief you can imagine, come to my site.
So, to those who say retroactive jealousy isn’t real, are you going to tell all those people that their experiences don’t matter?
All of this is a long-winded way of saying that, of course, retroactive jealousy is real.
It’s not something that only affects men, nor is it limited to men whose girlfriends have a certain amount of sexual experience. It’s also not something that only impacts straight men.
I’ve worked with many gay male clients and had people in my courses from all walks of life. All of this is to say that comments dismissing retroactive jealousy are ridiculous.
And if you don’t want to take my word for it, just do a quick search online.
Look on YouTube or explore other channels and voices on this topic—you’ll find endless evidence that retroactive jealousy is, without a doubt, a real thing.
This isn’t some made-up fantasy by people like me or just something that only guys with issues with women experience.
That’s simply not true. A related comment some of these trolls make, which I think is actually really harmful to retroactive jealousy sufferers, needs to be addressed.
For clarity, I’ve been posting about this issue for over 10 years now.
I’ve heard it all—people calling me names and saying all kinds of mean things. Honestly, I guess I’m lucky because it’s easy for me to brush it off. It doesn’t really bother me.
But every once in a while, I’ll come across a comment, and instead of thinking about myself, I’ll think about how another retroactive jealousy sufferer might feel reading it. That’s what inspired this video today.
Another version of this comment is: “If you struggle with retroactive jealousy, it means you should always break up with your partner because you’re in the wrong relationship.”
People post comments like this all the time, saying, “If this issue bothers you that much, you should just break up.”
You should move on and find someone whose past doesn’t bother you, right? Every time I read a comment like that, I think about the hundreds of husbands I’ve worked with who have incredible wives. These women have been loyal, loving, and truly devoted.
They adore their wives, who are supportive, loving presences in their lives. She’s a great mom and has built a wonderful home for the family.
I think to myself, would I tell that man he’s in the wrong relationship just because he’s struggling with retroactive jealousy?
He has a fantastic marriage, his kids love him, he loves them, and they have a good home life. She’s been loyal, never strayed, and they have so much going for them.
Are you really going to tell that man he should break up and that he’s in the wrong relationship just because he’s struggling with retroactive jealousy?
Of course not—it doesn’t make sense.
And that brings me to my final point in this video: retroactive jealousy is often what I would call irrational.
In other words, retroactive jealousy is often not rooted in a genuine conflict of values between you and your partner. It doesn’t necessarily mean that you and your partner don’t share the same values.
Just because you can’t stop thinking about your partner’s past doesn’t mean their past is a deal breaker.
So be cautious when taking advice from people who haven’t experienced retroactive jealousy and don’t understand the issue. Their advice can be quite damaging.
If you’d like more information about my work or you’d like to work with me one-on-one, please visit this page.
And be sure you’re subscribed to my YouTube channel as well to be notified of new videos.

![Is Retroactive Jealousy a Sign to Leave? 4 Questions to Ask Yourself [VIDEO] Is Retroactive Jealousy a Sign to Leave? 4 Questions to Ask Yourself [VIDEO]](https://www.retroactivejealousy.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/jefferson-sees-L4duIwxTrRA-unsplash.jpg)
![Retroactive Jealousy and Open Relationships: My Thoughts [VIDEO] Retroactive Jealousy and Open Relationships: My Thoughts [VIDEO]](https://www.retroactivejealousy.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/03/rob-keating-4sRGcbxEQHk-unsplash-scaled.jpg)
![Is Retroactive Jealousy About YOUR Past? Consider This [VIDEO] Is Retroactive Jealousy About YOUR Past? Consider This [VIDEO]](https://www.retroactivejealousy.com/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/l-a-GpesppB5B8w-unsplash-scaled.jpg)
